Mazda MX-6
An overlooked sporty sibling of the Ford Probe, the Mazda MX-6 combines impeccable Japanese engineering with sleek styling and agile handling. Though some people disregarded it in the ‘90s for its lack of high-performance badge, it’s a genuinely fun car to drive and a good-looking collectible.
Volvo 850 T-5R
It has been overshadowed by flashier European performance sedans since the 1990s, but the Volvo 850 T-5R remains an excellent collector car for those who love to go fast. Its boxy body contains a punchy turbocharged engine, and it’s also surprisingly practical for a car built for speed.
Mitsubishi Galant VR-4
It’s relatively known nowadays, but the Galant VR-4’s biggest problem was being released in the same decade as the iconic Mitsubishi Lancer Evolution series. It didn’t have the same mainstream appeal, but its turbocharged AWD system and refined design made it a sleeper classic.
Nissan 300ZX (Z32)
The second-gen Nissan 300ZX is one of the swiftest and most precise collector cars, with an iconic twin-turbocharged performance engine and attractive bodywork. Its tech was futuristic in the ‘90s, yet went underappreciated compared to flashier models, like the fourth-gen Toyota Supra, also being released.
Acura Vigor
It was only sold for two years, but the Acura Vigor was also underappreciated due to its fairly bland styling and a lack of high-profile marketing. It was smooth and responsive, with a top-notch four-cylinder engine and well-set chassis, but only real enthusiasts took a chance on it.
Oldsmobile Aurora
Critics dismissed the Aurora as just another American luxury fleet car, making it one of the most underrated Oldsmobiles ever. As a result, many ‘90s drivers missed out on its high-output V6 engine, smooth handling, and well-engineered chassis. Its rare styling makes it a top collectible car now.
Toyota Soarer (Z30)
It’s famous in Japan, but the Toyota Soarer never quite achieved the same fame in international markets. The third-gen ‘90s model was sporty and stylish, with a turbocharged engine that reached grand-touring speeds without issue. If only it had received more exposure!
Saab 900 NG
The Saab 900 NG was the “new” version of the original model, and while it had a strong legacy, it was often ignored by mainstream automotive enthusiasts. It was small and quirky, but packed full of turbocharged power. Its eccentric ‘90s charm deserved more appreciation.
BMW 318ti
By the time the 318ti hit the market, BMW had already garnered a reputation for building large, prestigious models, such as the M3 variants. The 318ti was a far more conservative car, so many overlooked it, even though it was sharp, agile, and surprisingly fast.
Infiniti J30
Designed to replace the M30, the ‘92 J30 was a breakaway from Infiniti’s usual sporty cars. Its sedan-like looks didn’t stand out to the majority, but it has since built a reputation as a collector car due to its classic V6 engine, luxurious interior, and smooth ride.
Chevrolet Beretta GTZ
This high-performance variant of the original Chevy Beretta should have been an instant classic, but it was lost among the many other 1990s speedsters. Its design wasn’t exactly eye-catching, but it drove with power and force, and it was also a great affordable collectible.
Chrysler LHS
It may have looked like just another luxury sedan in Chrysler’s long lineup, but the LHS was capable of so much more. This underrated ‘90s beauty was an effortless ride, with a refined design that prioritized driver experience and injected some understated luxury.
Mercury Cougar XR7
The seventh-gen Mercury Cougar XR7 was part of a $2 billion redesign project, yet it struggled to fully assert itself as a performance car. It was competing directly against the tenth-gen Ford Thunderbird, so its subtle sportiness was overlooked, pushing it into sleeper classic territory.
Ford Taurus SHO
We know it well enough now, but the Ford Taurus SHO was surprisingly overlooked in the 1990s. It had a Yamaha-tuned V6, sharp handling, and a sleek, heavy-set build that screamed “power”. Its design was just a little too family-sedan for daredevil drivers.
Dodge Avenger
Many collectors dismiss it as a plain midsize sedan with little to offer, but the original Dodge Avenger was actually a super-sporty beast on the road. It combined a V6 engine with a relatively lightweight build for efficiency, but the lack of appreciation means it's fairly rare now.
Honda Prelude (BA8)
It’s a name you probably recognize, but the third-gen Honda Prelude was massively overshadowed by the Civic and Integra in the ‘90s. Its styling divided opinions, causing collectors to overlook its precision, speed, and reliability in favor of other sporty models.
Mazda Eunos Cosmo
It had a cool name and a futuristic design, but the Mazda Eunos Cosmo was just a little too ahead of its time in the ‘90s. Its triple-rotor rotary engine and high-tech interior were intimidating back then, but now make it a firm collector favorite.
Toyota Sera
The Toyota Sera’s unique butterfly doors alone should make it a major collectible, but it was more of a quirky option back in the ‘90s. However, beneath that eye-catching design was Toyota’s trademark reliable engineering, which gave it the longevity it needed to become a classic.
Alfa Romeo 164S
The Alfa Romeo 164S was a high-performance variant of the original ‘80s model, but many people dismissed it as “too complicated”. But it had every quality a collector could want: power, speed, and refined handling. It just needed some real enthusiasts to appreciate it.
Mitsubishi FTO
The FTO is another Mitsubishi that lived in the Lancer Evo’s shadow in the ‘90s, and it has flown under the radar ever since. But many collectors now love its exciting driving dynamics, light, sporty design, and turbocharged engine. It’s also enticingly rare.
Opel Calibra Turbo
Overshadowed by its BMW and Volkswagen cousins, the Opel Calibra Turbo had potential but often ended up on the backburner. Luckily, collectors now appreciate its raw power, all-wheel drive, and sophisticated European styling, so it’s still present on the classic car market.
Plymouth Prowler
It looks cool, but we’re not surprised that most ‘90s drivers thought the Plymouth Prowler was impractical! Everything about it was radical and unapologetic, which is what makes it such a great collectible. It’s a powerful, unique retro throwback to the entire ‘90s era.
Buick Riviera Supercharged
Combining a solid car with a supercharged engine should create a hit, right? Wrong! The ‘90s Buick Riviera Supercharged was a quiet collectible without a firm audience, so its V6 power, performance engineering, and striking design were overlooked for a long time.
Chrysler Cirrus
High-performance cars weren’t the only ones being overlooked in the 1990s; family sedans like the sleek Chrysler Cirrus were met with similar disinterest. It was affordable and reliable, but not flashy, so most drivers underestimated this surprisingly fun car when it first launched.
Isuzu VehiCROSS
The Isuzu VehiCROSS was a vehicle that should have dominated the SUV market, but its styling was just a bit too odd to appeal to mainstream buyers. However, those who did choose it were pleasantly surprised by its exceptional AWD capabilities and robust construction, so it filled its niche.
Suzuki Cappuccino
Tiny, lightweight, and extremely quirky, the Suzuki Cappuccino certainly catches the eye. But the 1990s were full of prominent Japanese sports cars, and the Cappuccino didn’t quite make the cut, even with its remarkably swift handling and playful driving experience. Nowadays, it’s an underrated gem.
Porsche Boxster
You might struggle to believe it, but the first-gen Porsche Boxster was rather underrated compared to the brand’s more legendary models. It was an entry-level Porsche, so many overlooked it entirely, but still provided plenty of power, plus a well-balanced chassis and 911-inspired design.
Peugeot 306 GTI-6
The Peugeot 306 GTI-6 was a great car that was sadly released at a time when too many dominant competitors were thriving. It was a lively, six-speed hot hatch with understated styling that meant people often overlooked it. It’s hands-down one of the most underrated ‘90s performance cars.
Daihatsu Charade GTti
It looked like a simple, tiny economy car, but the ‘90s Daihatsu Charade GTti was hiding a huge secret: its rev-happy three-cylinder engine! The lightweight build made it incredibly nimble, and its quirky retro design has gained more popularity over the years.
Ford Puma
It’s a well-known collector car now, but the Ford Puma was far more introverted in the 1990s. Only big enthusiasts appreciated its agile handling, sleek, compact bodywork, and spirited four-cylinder engine. It’s playful, rare, and deserves even more recognition now.
Lotus Elan M100
The original Lotus Elan had been around since 1962, yet the ‘90s M100 variant wasn’t quite as popular. Many drivers underestimated it due to low production numbers, but it turned out to be sharp, lightweight, and fast; a true sports car and a relatively rare modern roadster.
Audi S8
It’s not quite the hulking beast that the 2025 S8 is, but the original Audi S8 was no slouch. It was immensely powerful and a great performance car, all wrapped up in conservatively-luxurious bodywork. It was simply less known than its closest competitors at the time.
Eagle Summit Wagon
Wagons were practical in the 1990s, but many drivers wanted something snazzier. The Eagle Summit Wagon was just a bit too bland-looking, though it was incredibly durable and versatile on all terrain. If collectors want a different type of ‘90s car, this is the one.
Citroen XM
Critics dismissed the Citroen XM as too complex or eccentric, so it never quite garnered mainstream appeal. However, nowadays, enthusiasts appreciate how futuristic its styling was for the ‘90s, and they get good use out of its hydroneumatic suspension and advanced mechanical engineering.
Geo Prizm GSI
The Geo Prizm GSI was likely underappreciated because it was only released between 1990 and 1992, but it’s far more than a rebadged Toyota. This car was both reliable and adventurous, as well as fast and fuel-efficient. It’s an overlooked classic that most collectors can afford.
